Peer Review Process

DIBACA JOURNAL
Peer Review Process
Ensuring academic quality, originality, and integrity through a rigorous peer-review process.
 
Review Policy

DIBACA: Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa dan Sastra Indonesia applies a peer-review process to evaluate the quality, originality, relevance, and academic contribution of submitted manuscripts. All manuscripts submitted to the journal are subject to editorial assessment and review by qualified reviewers with relevant expertise.

The journal employs a double-blind peer-review system, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process. This approach is intended to support objective, independent, and impartial scholarly evaluation.

REVIEW MODEL
Double-Blind Peer Review
Both authors and reviewers remain anonymous to one another during the evaluation process to help maintain fairness and objectivity.
AUTHOR
Identity concealed
⇄
REVIEWER
Identity concealed
EVALUATION CRITERIA
What Reviewers Evaluate

Reviewers assess the submitted manuscript based on the following academic aspects:

01 · RELEVANCE
Title and Abstract
Consistency between the title, abstract, research objectives, and the journal's focus and scope.
02 · SUBSTANCE
Discussion and Findings
Quality of the analysis, interpretation of research findings, and coherence of the discussion.
03 · CONCLUSION
Conclusions
Alignment between the conclusions, research questions, objectives, and reported findings.
04 · ORIGINALITY
Novelty
Originality of the research, its new insights, and its contribution to language education, linguistics, or literature.
05 · SIGNIFICANCE
Scientific Impact
The significance and potential contribution of the manuscript to academic knowledge and scholarly practice.
06 · REFERENCES
Reference Quality
Relevance, adequacy, accuracy, and scholarly quality of the references cited in the manuscript.
EDITORIAL WORKFLOW
Review Stages
 
STAGE 01
Manuscript Submission
Authors submit their manuscripts through the DIBACA online journal system in accordance with the author guidelines.
 
STAGE 02
Initial Editorial Assessment
The editorial team examines the manuscript's relevance to the journal's focus and scope, completeness, and general compliance with submission requirements.
 
STAGE 03
Double-Blind Peer Review
The manuscript is evaluated by reviewers with relevant expertise. Reviewers provide critical assessments and recommendations to improve the manuscript's academic quality.
 
STAGE 04
Editorial Decision and Revision
Based on the reviewers' reports, the editor communicates the editorial decision and, where applicable, requests revisions from the authors.
 
STAGE 05
Final Decision and Publication
The editor makes the final decision after considering the review reports and the authors' revisions. Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, layout, and publication.
EDITORIAL DECISION
Possible Review Outcomes
Accept
Accepted for publication.
Minor Revision
Minor changes are required.
Major Revision
Substantial revisions are required.
Reject
The manuscript is not accepted.
Commitment to Academic Integrity
DIBACA is committed to maintaining an objective, transparent, and responsible peer-review process to ensure the quality and integrity of every published article.