Retraction or Corrections

DIBACA JOURNAL POLICIES
Post-Publication Corrections and Retractions Policy
Maintaining the accuracy, transparency, and integrity of the scholarly record.
 
Policy Statement

DIBACA: Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa dan Sastra Indonesia is committed to maintaining the accuracy, reliability, and integrity of the scholarly record. When errors, inaccuracies, or concerns are identified in published articles, the journal may issue an appropriate correction, clarification, expression of concern, retraction, withdrawal, or removal notice, depending on the nature and seriousness of the case.

General Principles

All post-publication actions are intended to ensure transparency and preserve the integrity of academic communication. The editorial team evaluates each case individually, taking into account the nature of the error, its impact on the article's findings and conclusions, and the available evidence.

01 | ARTICLE CORRECTION
Correction

A correction is issued to address errors in a published article that do not invalidate the overall validity of the article. The original article may be updated, accompanied by a separate correction notice explaining the changes.

02 | PUBLISHING OR PRODUCTION ERROR
Erratum

An erratum traditionally refers to a correction of an error introduced during the production or publication process. It may address mistakes such as incorrect author affiliations, formatting, or other publication details. The terminology may vary between publishers.

03 | AUTHOR-RELATED ERROR
Corrigendum

A corrigendum traditionally refers to a correction of an error in an already published article that originates from the author(s). It is used to clarify or correct information while maintaining the original article as part of the scholarly record.

04 | ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Addendum

An addendum is an additional publication that provides important information, analysis, or clarification related to a previously published article. It supplements the original work without invalidating or replacing it.

05 | PENDING INVESTIGATION
Expression of Concern

An expression of concern is a public notice indicating that there are serious concerns about a published article, but the available evidence or investigation is not yet sufficient to reach a final decision. It alerts readers while the matter is being investigated.

06 | INVALIDATION OF PUBLISHED WORK
Retraction

A retraction is an action indicating that a published article can no longer be relied upon as part of the scholarly record. Reasons may include unreliable findings, serious errors, plagiarism, or other forms of publication misconduct. The original article is generally retained in the publication record but clearly marked as retracted.

07 | WITHDRAWAL FROM PUBLICATION
Withdrawal

Withdrawal refers to the removal of a publication from the publication process, particularly before or during the early publication stage, such as the Article in Press stage. Withdrawal may also occur because of publication or production errors. A separate withdrawal notice may be issued to maintain transparency.

08 | EXCEPTIONAL CONTENT REMOVAL
Removal

Removal is an exceptional action in which the article's content is removed from normal public access. The bibliographic record and a removal notice are retained to preserve transparency and document the reason for the action.

Editorial Assessment and Decision

When a potential error or concern is reported or identified, the editorial team will assess the available information and determine the appropriate action. The assessment may include:

Verification of the Report

Reviewing the reported error, supporting evidence, and relevant parts of the published article.

Consultation and Clarification

Seeking clarification from the relevant authors, editors, reviewers, institutions, or other parties when necessary.

Editorial Decision

Determining the appropriate corrective action based on the evidence, seriousness of the issue, and its implications for the scholarly record.

Publication of a Notice

Publishing an appropriate notice and maintaining a clear connection between the notice and the original article, where applicable.

Transparency and Scholarly Record

DIBACA is committed to ensuring that post-publication changes are communicated transparently. Where applicable, correction, expression of concern, retraction, withdrawal, or removal notices will be clearly identified and linked to the relevant publication record. The journal aims to preserve an accurate and transparent scholarly record for readers, researchers, and the academic community.

DIBACA: Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa dan Sastra Indonesia
Published by PenKreatif Publisher in collaboration with STIS As-Saadah